Everything for Sale: How Controversial Adverts Work, Then and Now

“Sell, sell, sell” is the familiar rallying cry of aggressive salespeople everywhere. For generations, the technical and psychological craft of steering our appetite for new things has kept evolving. We may believe we already know every market trick, yet now and then marketers still catch us off guard with their “innovative” trends.

“Greenwashing” in Marketing

These days nobody is surprised that every advert mentions ecology. No CEO of a major corporation (especially those in oil, plastic or cars) would make a public appearance without pledging a lifelong commitment to protecting the natural environment. That behaviour is understandable. It cannot be denied that humans have a negative impact on our planet's climate. This tragic circumstance does not change the fact that money can be made from it. The term “greenwashing” is a well-known marketer's gimmick. Cynical reliance on “ecology” in commercial campaigns has become not only common but practically obligatory.

Even More Radical: “Wokewashing”

Next to “greenwashing” came an even more radical term: “wokewashing”. This time ecology has been replaced by social problems. Whatever the product, marketing is now obliged to invoke noble slogans about fighting racial, ethnic and gender inequality. The natural home for promoting such ideas should of course be social organisations, religious communities, schools, families and circles of friends. Unfortunately, the main players shaping our understanding of the world are corporate advertising agencies.

We cannot escape the fruits of their labour.

The endless stream of advertisements offers hard proof of how progressive they are, and their efforts reassure the public that their clients remain sensitive to historical and social injustices. Being “woke (“aware”) is meant to build and strengthen a loyal customer base.

Kendall Jenner, the youngest of the Kardashian family , with a can of Pepsi Cola in hand, stops potential racial riots. © Pepsico

It is not hard to guess that this is simply a cynical game. As a rule, “conscious” companies cannot show how they realistically influence their ideals of improving social life. Every advertising campaign, even when backed by slogans of social justice, has one main goal: money. For companies, noble programmes are just a new, well-functioning way of reaching customers.

"Virtue has never been as respectable as money”

Nothing More Than Media Manipulation

Of course, no reasonable person would undermine the basic principles of marketing, whose main purpose is to sell an idea or a commodity at any cost. No reasonable person would question that advertisements are not meant to reflect reality but to project a desired future. Still, one should also accept the principle that even marketing cannot falsify reality. Showing a world that does not exist is plain manipulation. Today, in times of an unprecedented and fierce ideological struggle, or “culture war” for short, we are shown a world we will not recognise once we step out of our own home. This happens not as an exception but on a regular basis.

For advertising agencies our reality does not exist, or it looks like a kind of oddity not worth referring to. It is unclear whether free will, creativity or simple populism means that ads leaving marketing workshops must necessarily “contain” every popular social problem. All of it is to be elegantly packed into 25-second videos or announcements. These ads are often so absurd that they bring a smile rather than serious reflection on the state of our world. Too often, instead of pondering real problems, questions arise: how did they manage to squeeze all the binding dogmas into one advert, and from which country or continent were these ads brought to be shown in our homes? Their authenticity is as great as that of Netflix's historical series.

Benetton: The Scandalous Brand

Commercialization of major social problems by omnipotent corporations is not an invention of our time. This phenomenon has existed for many generations. I would like to remind you the company that forty years ago recognized that our problems are an excellent opportunity to increase the company’s recognition and obtain sales growth. The Italian company Benetton, causing scandals with its advertisements, achieved undoubted success on the market.

In 1982 Benetton began working with the photographer Oliviero Toscani, who had already shocked public opinion many times before. He became best known for his 2007 campaign. The image of a naked, emaciated anorexic woman that he used in an advertising campaign drew approval from the fashion world and anger from doctors. The image of Isabelle Caro, a young French woman weighing only 31 kilograms and looking like a concentration-camp victim, appeared on billboards and on the front pages of Italian newspapers. The campaign was paid for by the Italian company Flash & Partners to publicise a clothing brand for young women. The head of ABA (Research Association for Anorexia and Bulimia) called Toscani's controversial photo “extremely harsh”. Corriere della Sera, Italy's best-selling newspaper, signalled its disapproval by refusing to publish the ad.

controversial benetton advert cementary with white crosses
Controversial Benetton advert, 1991 Cemetery, © Benetton 1991

Adverts That Sparked Outrage

The public should not be so surprised by the results of Oliviero Toscani’s work. Most of the recipients probably remembered previous projects commissioned by Benetton. Although the shocking image of the bull being killed and falling to the ground had nothing to do with the company’s products, the imprint “United Colors of Benetton” was memorized. With images of the Yugoslavian war and images of the death of the African people starving to death, Benetton used the violent emotional reaction of the viewer and based on this reaction, imprinted his brand in the minds of the audience. Benetton confirmed the psychological thesis that in order to achieve the desired effect, an advert must tug on emotions of the recipient. Emotions carry the message in advertising. The message does not have to contain any relevant information. Someone who does not know that Benetton produces clothing will not find out that from their advertising, but if they see this company’s products in store, it will trigger their memory.

For many people, Toscani's advertising campaigns for Benetton were no longer merely controversial. Some called them scandalous. Benetton argued that its campaigns, using outrageous photos, were a voice on discrimination, armed conflict, deadly disease and other global problems.

Toscani's campaigns opened a new era in the history of marketing. The artist showed that rising sales come from a long and consistent communication strategy. It was the strategy Benetton used, and it was very simple: be visible, be controversial, touch feelings and become permanently fixed in people's minds. Thanks to this, Benetton became a true record holder when it came to boycotts against a clothing company. Controversial advertisements showing a priest and a nun kissing, copulating horses or adverts in defence of HIV-positive people were repeatedly withdrawn from city streets and the press.

controversial benetton advert priest kissing nun
Controversial Benetton advert, 1991 Priest and nun, © Benetton 1991

How Sweden Reacted

In Sweden, too, not everyone was delighted with what Benetton was showing. In 1993 the Ombudsman for Discrimination of Consumers filed a complaint against Benetton with the Market Ethics Council (MER).

“The Ombudsman for Discrimination received a private complaint about the advert with the white and black girl. The Ombudsman questions the ad, points out that it is inconsistent with good business practice and concludes that the white girl has an angelic appearance, while the black girl's hairstyle resembles “devil's horns”. The complainant considers the advertisement offensive and racist.”

“The Ombudsman points out that the photos have nothing to do with the products Benetton sells and that some people feel uncomfortable about exploiting the tragic fate of others. Consequently, the question was raised whether Benetton's advertisement was designed in an offensive manner, whether it adversely affected public trust in advertising and whether it was therefore contrary to the basic principles of marketing.”

controversial benetton advert devil angel
Controversial Benetton advert, 1991 angel and devil © Benetton 1986

The Market Ethics Council (MER) confirmed that “Benetton's advertisements have nothing to do with, or otherwise contain any information about, the company's products, and do not even generally relate to the company's business activities. The only text is the phrase “United Colors of Benetton”. However, in MER's opinion, none of the images in question can be described as vulgar, indecent or otherwise clearly inappropriate. Even if the published advertisement arouses antipathy among some and may in that sense be perceived as inappropriate, MER cannot consider it inconsistent with the basic principles of advertising.

A Sophisticated, Cynical Technique

Benetton's disputes over its ads do not change the obvious fact that this advertising is not about real, painful concern and compassion but a sophisticated, cynical technique for growing the customer base through alleged humanitarian compassion and a non-racist offer. Behind the company's supposed involvement lies an obvious desire for profit. Any form of advertising is good advertising, and the bigger the bang it makes, the better. Publicity, after all, is the best and often free form of marketing.

controversial benetton advert immigrants
Controversial Benetton advert, 1986 globes © Benetton 1986

Despite the many similarities between Benetton's marketing forty years ago and today's wave of various “washing” activities, there is a fundamental difference. Benetton was a relatively small company, almost alone in this kind of marketing. Today we are dealing with large companies acting en masse on the crest of a global trend. Forty years ago Benetton had the courage to go against the trends, to take a risk and bet on something unique and shocking. That courage brought it fame and brand recognition. Today we face widespread opportunism that cynically exploits social problems for the classic “sell, sell, sell”.

Where Is Benetton Today?

The answer is fairly simple: “it could be better.” Over time, customers seem to have understood that the company probably put too much energy into marketing and not enough into developing and improving the quality of the products it tries to sell.

Benetton shop in 2022
Benetton shop in 2022, The gentle face of a former rebel © Stalmar Publication

Benetton did not take over the main shopping streets of big cities. Without its extreme marketing tactics, it became just one of many brands, squeezed between GAP and H&M.

Share

Chicago - Maxwell Street

In the not-so-distant past, these were points on the map marking places where unusual things happened, and where revolutionary ideas were born that changed the

Read more »

Controversial advertising works because it trades on feeling rather than information. Whether the cause is the environment, social justice or a shocking image, the goal stays the same: to be noticed, remembered and talked about. Looking back at Benetton's campaigns alongside today's greenwashing and wokewashing shows how that logic has shifted from a single risk-taking brand to a widespread corporate habit.